Top 10 Best Eyeliner for Lash Extensions In 2023

Eyeliner is one makeup product that would go very close to the lash extension line and choosing the right one that would not collide with your lash extensions is only a matter of need. But finding the best out of dozens of eyeliners in the market is not that easy. So check out our picks of the 10 best eyeliners for lash extensions.

Top 10 Best Eyeliner for Lash Extensions In 2023

Image	Product Name	Price On Amazon
	Best Overall LLBA Liquid Eyeliner	Check Price
	Best Waterproof Matte Eyeliner NYX PROFESSIONAL	Check Price
	Best Safe Eyeliner For Lash Extension Eyeable Liquid Liner by BL Lashes	Check Price
	Best Eyeliner For Sensitive Eyes Maybelline Eyestudio Liquid Eyeliner	Check Price
	Best Extension Friendly Liquid Eyeliner Cartier Lashes	Check Price
	Best Mechanical Black Eyeliner Maybelline Mechanical Black Eyeliner	Check Price
	Best Waterproof Eyeliner for Lash Extension Revlon Pencil Eyeliner	Check Price
	Best Pitch Black Eyeliner for Lash Extension MAYBELLINE Hyper Eyeliner	Check Price
	Best Long-Lasting Eyeliner for lash Extension Maybelline Sharpenable Eyeliner Pencil	Check Price
	Best Everyday Use Eyeliner stila Stay All Day Eye Liner	Check Price

1. Best Overall Lash Extensions Eyeliner – LLBA Liquid Eyeliner

Specification

• Brand: LLBA
• Color: Black
• Item Form: Ink
• Finish Type: Shimmery
• Special Feature:  Waterproof
• Product Benefits: Oil Free

Description

LLBA Liquid Eyeliner is the best one for lash extensions that will stay up to 12 hours and will give you the perfect line effortlessly with its precise ultra-fine tip. This vegan, cruelty-free liner will brighten up your eyes with the dark intense, smudge-proof stroke.

Features

• Vegan, cruelty-free: this eyeliner is vegan and cruelty made without the touch of any kind of harsh chemicals that would not clash with your lash extensions but give you the perfect eyeliner to create any look of your choice.
• Ultra-fine tip: LLBA eyeliner has an ultra-fine tip that gives the most precise line in your eyes which is everyone’s dream. This fine tip would help you to create a line very precisely and glide on easily without stressing your lash extension line.
• Waterproof: this eyeliner stays on your eyes for 12 hours straight without smudging or giving you the eyes of a raccoon. You can have your eyeliner on without having to worry about getting it on the lash extension.

How to use

• Finish your eye makeup before applying or apply some primer.
• Apply the liner with a clean stroke.
• Try not to shake your hands while applying.
• Make your desirable wing with the precise tip.
• Clean it up with a brush and some concealer.

Expert Verdict

Ever since I put on my lash extension I have been searching for the perfect eyeliner that would have all the qualities in one. While I was searching I found a gem like this in the LLBA Liquid Eyeliner. This liner just upgraded my eyeliner game to a newer level and I cannot just get enough of this one. I am so impressed with the thin liner because of how precisely I can draw my liners. I can go for any type of look even with all the las extensions. I find it even easier to use as the tip is not harsh. It would never be enough no matter how much I talk about the intense color. It gives me a jet-black eye with just one stroke. I am not that good with eyeliners but I barely mess up with this one. In this scorching summer, LLBA has been my lifesaver. For that, I would consider this to be my top product on this list!

Pros and Cons

2. Best Waterproof Matte Eyeliner – NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner

Specification

• Brand: NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
• Color: Black
• Item Form: Liquid
• Finish Type: Matte
• Special Feature: Waterproof

Description

Experience the best waterproof matte liner with NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner. Get the perfect slender line with the supple brush tip. This cruelty-free, vegan formula will make you look sassy effortlessly.

Features

Waterproof: this eyeliner is completely waterproof which would give you a complete matte look. When you have your lash extension done having a liner that would not run into those pretty lashes is important. This line is going to serve in those aspects.

Safe: this liner is vegan and cruelty-free which makes it safe for your lash extension since there is no harmful chemical. This would also nourish and help your eye area.

How to use

• Prepare your eyes before applying eyeliner.
• You can press some powder over your eyes or can use a primer for better results.
• Draw liner precisely without shaking the hands too much.
• Clean it up with some concealer for a precise look.

Expert Verdict

I am someone who has tried all the liquid liners on the planet in order to find the one that would not give me dark circles through their leakage. Since I am a consent lash extension user I have to be very careful of my eyeliner choice. I have got this NYX liner and this just ticks all the boxes becoming one of my holy grails. This liner would glide on your eyes like butter and you would not feel anything going into your eyes. This does not bleed into my lashes. whenever I come back from a long shift and see the liner perfectly fine in my eyes I feel so happy. This liner has been my number one over the high-end brands cause this is not ripping me off and serving me all the goodness in one pack. This super affordable liner lasts forever and gives me the most perfect dark line ever. I am not going back anywhere without this.

Pros and Cons

3. Best Safe Eyeliner For Lash Extension – Eyeable Liquid Liner by BL Lashes | Eyelash extension friendly eyeliner

Specification

• Brand: BL Lashes
• Color: Black
• Item Form: Liquid
• Special Feature: Long lasting
• Product Benefits: Long Lasting

Description

Eyeable Liquid Liner by BL Lashes makes your bold look last all day long without causing any buildup in your lash line. Its precise tip glide easily without causing trouble to your lash extension band. Create any look to express your character with the best safe eyeliner for lash extensions and get rid of any fear of harming your lash extensions.

Features

• Formula:  This liner has a formula that does not cause any kind of build-up on your lash line. This is specially formulated for the eyelash extension so it would not harm those lashes.
• Easy to apply: this liner has a precise tip that makes the application very easy. This can make the perfect thin liner. You can always make the liner thickness according to your choice and place it however you like it.
• Long-lasting: This liner would stay on your eyes for a long time without smudging and running into your lashes, which is a very important feature for people with lash extensions.
• Easy to remove: this liner lasts for a long time on your eyes but does not stick to your eyes and makes the removal irritating rather it is very easy to remove. You can just wash it off with some warm water. For some, this might not be a huge thing but lash extensions need gentle care so the removal of liner is a vital thing to consider.

How to use

• Start with preparing your eyes. If applying with makeup make sure to finish your eye look first.
• Apply some primer or powder if applying on a bare face.
• To apply like a pro, you can start with a dot at the end of your eyes where you want your wing to end.
• Then dot at the middle.
• Connect those dots with the fine liner and voila you have a perfect liner.

Expert Verdict

Finally, I got a liner that does not flake or smudge over my lash extensions. I was so skeptical about liner after I got my lash extensions and after all this time I have found the perfect one.  I was very worried about the precise tip and not being able to draw a thick liner I like but this is even better. I can draw a perfectly thick line with this one. I love how smoothly it goes into my eyes. Some tips would be so harsh that it would feel like your skin ripping off but this tip did not feel that harsh. I am generally very sensitive so you can use this without worrying much. I was wearing this just today in the scorching sun but this thing did not move so I am really happy. I will recommend this to anyone with lash extensions and trying to save those beautiful things.

Pros and Cons

4. Best Eyeliner For Sensitive Eyes – Maybelline Eyestudio Master Precise All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

Specification

• Brand: MAYBELLINE
• Color: Black
• Item Form: Liquid
• Finish Type: Natural
• Special Feature: Good for sensitive eyes

Description

Maybelline Eyestudio Master Precise All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner is the best liner for sensitive eyes out there. This smudge-proof, waterproof, fragrance-free, ophthalmologist and dermatologist-tested liner will give your eyes the perfect line that is going to last all day long making your eye look game step ahead.

Features

• Liquid pen: this eyeliner has a liquid pen that glides easily on your eyes without being too harsh. This gives you the jet-black liner.
• Precise application: the perfect thin tip helps you to achieve a precise application. With the help of this fine tip, you can place the liner in the place of your choice without any problem.
• Long-lasting: this liner will last on your eyes for 12 hours straight without making your eyes irritated and your lash extensions any problems.
• Sensitive eye safe: this liner has been proven to be safe for sensitive eyes. This does not irritate the eye line or cause any kind of tension to the lash extension.

How to use

• Prep your eyelids for eyeliner with some primer or powder.
• Apply the precise tip eyeliner in the outer corner at first.
• Create a wig of your choice.
• Bring the liner to the inner corner of your eyes and make a straight line.

Expert Verdict

Absolutely love this eyeliner. This is coming from someone with sensitive eyes and has lash extensions on. As you can understand choosing a good eyeliner for e is the most difficult thing but this eyeliner has managed to mark all the boxes checked and got my heart. I am just too bad at eyeliner because my hand shakes every time I try to do it. But this one glides really easily on my eyes. This does not bleed into my lashes nor does it comes off after some time. It is totally safe for sensitive eyes that is what alone makes me fall for it but it has much more to offer. Its tip is perfectly thin and precise for a quick small wing or just a small line near my eye. The size of this liner is so adorable that I can fit this into my bag pocket or anywhere I want to. I would definitely recommend you to try this one for once it is value for money. oh, I also use this one often for my perfect bold lines. I just love those look with this eyeliner.

Pros and Cons

5. Best Extension Friendly Liquid Eyeliner – Cartier Lashes Amazing Oil Free Eyelash Extension Friendly Black Liquid Eyeliner

Specification

• Brand: Cartier lashes
• Color: Black
• Material Type Free: Oil Free
• Finish Type: Glossy
• Special Feature: Flexible

Description

Cartier Lashes Amazing oil-free eyelash extension friendly black liquid eyeliner is an oil-free best extension friendly liquid eyeliner. That would give you the most perfect line with just one stroke. This liner gives you the flexibility to express your personal style.

Features

• Oil-free: this liner is oil-free and does not leak oil from the liner like some other liners. persons with oily lids can easily get the desired look with this liner.
• Pigment: this liner has a very pigmented black color that gives the perfect look to your eyes. You can style the liner however you want to.
• Ultra-fine brush: this liner has a very ultra-fine brush that would give you a very precise fine line.

How to use

• You can directly apply the liner to your eyes.
• Draw dots over your eyelids and at the end of the eye.
• Connect the dots to get the perfect winged liner or any other look of your choice.

Expert Verdict

This is one of the best lash extension friendly eyeliners out there, to be honest. I do not know why more people are not talking about this liner but everyone should know how beautiful this thing is. I got this liner a few months ago and when I tried it on I did not think much but everyone was complimenting me about how pretty and vibrant my liner was looking. All my pictures come so pretty with this liner cannot even tell you. This has an ultra-fine brush that helps me to go to the exact area I want my liner to be and draw the preferred line of my choice. This is totally oil-free so it does not make my already oily lids oilier. I am so happy about it; this is one of the enemies of lash extensions as you all know. This does mean when it says it is lash extension friendly. If you have lash extensions on, try this one and you will never go back.

Pros and Cons

6. Best Mechanical Black Eyeliner – Maybelline New York Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Black Eyeliner

Specification

• Brand: MAYBELLINE
• Color: ONYX
• Finish Type: Natural
• Item Form: Pencil
• Special Feature:  Smudge Resistant, Waterproof

Description

Getting a deep black rich shade would be easier with the Maybelline New York Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Black Eyeliner. The best Mechanical Black Eyeliner out there, which will give you control over your lines providing definition and boldness.

Features

• Self-sharpening:  this eyeliner can sharpen its tip by itself so you would be in control of how precise your tip is and it will help you to achieve the most precise tip every time.
• Creamy formula: this liner has a very creamy formula that would give you the most perfect liner with just one stroke making it very easy to go for any look of your choice.
• Smudge resistant: this waterproof formula makes the eyeliner smudge-proof so you can easily be applied to your eyes. This can define your waterline without making them feel tacky or smudging them. This will give you the boldest look ever.

How to use

• Start lining at the inner corner of your eyelid.
• Draw the line along your lash line.
• End with the desired wing at the end.
• Tight line your eyes if needed.

Expert Verdict

This mechanical liner is my absolute favorite. I have been using this one for quite some time now and love this one constantly. I am not that good at liners but this liner helps me every time. Whenever I do not have enough time for my eyeliner I can easily draw it quickly with these mechanical liners. And the best part is you can sharpen it to make the precise tip of your choice whenever you like. Since I have my lash extensions on some eyeliners will ruin them but with this one, I do not have to worry about it because it doesn’t bleed into my lashes ruining them. Taking it off my eyes is also very easy. I often use this liner for tight lining which gives my eyes a little bit more shape. It does last me all day and I can go onto my nights without thinking about smudging this is just great since I do not have much time to reapply eyeliners.

Pros and Cons

7. Best Waterproof Eyeliner for Lash Extension – Revlon Pencil Eyeliner

Specification

• Brand: REVLON
• Color: Black
• Finish Type: Matte
• Special Feature: Waterproof
• Item Form: Pencil

Description

Create a versatile, bold, intense eye-look with Revlon Pencil Eyeliner. This will easily glide onto your eyes staying over 24 hours. The precise sharpable tip will give you the perfect sharp line or create a smoky look with the attached smudger. 

Features

• Intense color: this liner has a very intense color that gives you the boldest and most intense eye look of all time. This would make you achieve the jet-black look without trying too much.
• Waterproof: this is the best waterproof eyeliner out there that would last you for 24 hours without making you like a dark-eyed raccoon.
• Smudger: this eyeliner has a built-in smudger that helps you to achieve the perfect smoky, smoldering eyes. Apart from the smudger, it helps you achieve any other look of your choice.

How to use

• Start from the inner corner and drag the line to the end of your eyes.
• For a perfect wing draw some dots in the middle and outer corners of your eyes and join those dots.
• Draw a line and smudge it slowly with the smudger for achieving the perfect smoky look.  You can add some eyeshadow too if you want.

Expert Verdict

I am very pleased with this liner. I have been using various liners over the years since I started to get my lash extensions but was very scared to try on a pencil liner like this one.  Now that I am using this one for some time I can say Revlon knows what they are doping. First thing first, this lasts me forever. I have used this liner at pool parties, in my longest shifts and trips and this has never disappointed me. I have not ended me with dark smudges around my eyes or irritation. I am really happy that I got my hands on them. Now I have to worry less about finding another eyeliner because it does it all for me. The nicest addition to this great eyeliner is that it has a smudger attached that can easily give you the best smoky eye look ever. I am not that much of an eye makeup person but whenever I am trying something extra I will just put some of the eyeliner on and smudge it with the smudger and voila I have the most perfect stunning smoky eyes. Be sure to give this one a try.

Pros and Cons

8. Best Pitch Black Eyeliner for Lash Extension – MAYBELLINE Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Eyeliner

Specification

• Brand: MAYBELLINE
• Color: Pitch Black
• Item Form: Liquid
• Finish Type: Satin
• Special Feature: flex tip brush

Description

MAYBELLINE Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Eyeliner makes your liner go without any slips, skips, or struggles. With the hyper-easy brush, it fits your eye shape perfectly giving the grip to draw any style of your choice. Best pitch black eyeliner for lash extensions that would last 24 hours.

Features

• Hyper easy brush: this eyeliner has the most perfect brush that makes the line go very easy. This brush can glide with the shape of your eyes gripping it. With this optimal grip, you are able to draw any kind of shape.
• Good for sensitive eyes: this eyeliner has been ophthalmologist tested which makes it suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lenses.
• Long-lasting: This eyeliner lasts for a long time without smudging. This has the potential to last on your eyes for 24 hours.

How to use

• Draw your liner along the lash line from the inner corner.
• Let the liner dry for 20 seconds.
• Apply the wing of your choice.

Expert Verdict

I have hooded eyes with the lash extensions on and I love this liner. Maybelline is a game-changer for me. I tried it for the first time and fell in love, since then I am a Maybelline hyper-easy fan. This liner just lives up to its name because it is hyper-easy to apply. This brush is not just any other kind of brush that would give you that harsh line but it would glide onto your lids. Having a lot of small bristles this follows the shape of your eyes. This just makes the application 1000 times easier. It just touches the areas I want the pen to and does not touch my lashes which is great. I do not need to worry about my extensions getting dirty. It lasts for a long time on my eyes even though my eyelids are pretty oily. Overall I am loving this product and would recommend it to anyone else.

Pros and Cons

9. Best Long-Lasting Eyeliner for lash Extension – Maybelline New York TattooStudio Long-Lasting Sharpenable Eyeliner Pencil

Specification

• Brand: MAYBELLINE
• Color: Deep onyx, Arctic skies, Bold brown, Bronze glitz, Deep teal, and others
• Item Form: Gel, Pencil
• Finish Type: Matte
• Special Feature: waterproof, pigmented

Description

Maybelline New York TattooStudio Long-Lasting Sharpenable Eyeliner Pencil gives you the most perfect line that is rich in hues. This pencil will glide on your lids seamlessly and have precisely defined eyes. This is the best long-lasting eyeliner that lasts on your lash extensions for 36 hours. 

Features

• Waterproof: this liner will last on your eyes for 36 hours, you can go on with your daily life without having to worry about your liners getting messy and this can be perfect for daily use or summertime.
• Pigmentation: This eyeliner gives you the rich pigmented hue that you can ever have. You can get your eyes colored with this eyeliner anytime you want.
• Create different looks: create any liners of your choice. With the Sharpenable liner tip, you can achieve any look of your choice. Be it a winged liner or a smoky vibe you can get any of it.

How to use

• Prepare your eyes with some primer or powder.
• Add your preferred liner to your eyes.
• You can add a white liner on the bottom of the eyes to open them up a little.

Expert Verdict

When you have lash extensions on, you will be intimidated to opt for any eyeliner because it goes very close to the lashes and not having a good eyeliner can make your lashes fall off. But with this eyeliner, I am not afraid about my lashes. this liner glides on my eyes so easily that I cannot even describe it. I have used so many pencil li8ners so far but each of them has ended up being harsh on my eyelids but not this one. I use this one to tight line my eyes too and this just gives me the most dramatic looks I have ever wanted. The color is so intense that I am in love. You can achieve the perfect amount of color with one stroke. This is going to last on you as long as you don’t remove it I bet. I will be going on with my day and night without even touching it up for once and this liner will stay the same as the time I applied it6. This just blows my mind away. I will recommend you to try it for one at least.

Pros and Cons

10. Best Everyday Use Eyeliner – stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

Specification

• Brand: Stila
• Color:  Dark Brown, Alloy, Intense Black, Intense Jade, others
• Item Form:  Liquid
• Finish Type:  Matte
• Special Feature:  precise application, felt tip applicator for easy, Goes on smoothly

Description

stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner is an easily applicable, waterproof, liquid liner that would be the best for everyday use. This goes on smoothly on your eyes without skipping, smudging, or pulling. The fine tip of this eyeliner makes the application even easier.

Features

• Precise tip: this liner has a precise tip that would give you the most perfect liners. You can apply any kind of eye look with this one. Its precise tip would help you to achieve the liner in the perfect place of your choice.
• Waterproof: This holds up to the water pretty easily and does not run down when contacted with water.  It does not wear off underwater.
• Fast drying: being an everyday use eyeliner fast drying is very important and it does dry up pretty fast. The wait time after applying it on is not that much so you can use the liner without much worry.
• Smudge-proof: this liner would not smudge on your lids on you can easily wear this on your day-to-day work without much worry.

How to use

• Apply some primer or powder before applying the line.
• Shake the pencil very well.
• Sweep the pen liner across your eyes.
• Let it dry for a few seconds.
• Store the liner horizontally.

Expert Verdict

I got it on sale and have never gone back to any other liner for daily use. Since I got my lash extensions I am being very careful about every product I choose so it would not rip my lashes off. This one I was not that sure about but got it anyway and oh my this was a great choice. This may smudge a little if you do not let it dry completely but when it does dry it is just amazing it lasts all day. I go to the gym with this one on and I can tell you it does not come off. The tip is really my favorite. It can be manipulated very easily and I can make any shape of my choice. This brush is capable of drawing details and it is just highly responsive. This is hands down the best eyeliner for me. I am wearing it every day and doing pretty fine with my lash extension, this does not irritate my eyes, does not come off in the heat, stays intact all day and I can draw detailed liner with the tip. What more can I ask from a liner? So it is worth the money for me.

Pros and Cons

How Do You Brush Eyelash Extensions?

Brushing your lash extensions is very important if you don’t brush your lash extensions on a daily basis you may end up with tangled lashes and your natural lashes may fall off. If you neglect to brush your lash extensions, they would not look nice but rather very tacky. Here’s how you can brush your lash extensions:

• Clean dry lashes: Make sure you have clean dry lashes before brushing them. You would want to splash some water on your face and make sure there is no dust on the lashes. you can blow dry them if needed.
• Brush them from above: Start brushing your lashes from above first. Start brushing from the above close to your lash line with a clean spoolie. Gently roll your spoolie downward towards the tips.do the brushing in a rolling motion all the way.
• Brush from below: After you have finished brushing the upper portion of your lashes bring the spoolie underneath your lash line and do the brushing in the rolling motion same as before. Start from the roots and come all the way to the tips.

✨ You May like: Top 9 Best Primer For Estee Lauder Double Wear In 2023

How Do You Maintain Eyelash Extensions With Oily Skin?

Taking care of and maintaining lash extensions in oily skin can be very tough. But it is not impossible to get lash extensions on oily skin. Depending on the oiliness of your skin you just need to provide extra care to your lash extensions. Here are some tips I would give for your lash extensions if you have oily skin.

• Make sure to wash your face wherever it feels oily. It is recommended that you wash your face at least two times with proper care and gentleness to your lashes to get rid of all the oil from your lashes and your eyelids.
• Moisturize after washing your face. If you are not using a moisturizer after washing your face, then you are going to end up with oil; often. Moisturizers can help you oil control. Do not put it on the lashes rather put the moisturizer on your lids.
• Wipe your lids often. Since the oil on your eyelids is the thing that is going to interact with your eyelashes then it is best to wipe it out. This way your oil would not get into the lashes making them oily and sticky.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

Lash extensions need very gentle care and any product that goes around them needs to be thoroughly examined. Some products can make the lash extensions fall off. Eyeliner is something that can directly get in contact with the lash extensions so it is best to be very careful about the eyeliner choice and opt for expert suggestions. Since there are many eyeliners out there it can be very difficult to choose from according to your needs. So here you can find the best overall eyeliner that will check all the boxes for the ones with lash extensions and even for those without lash extensions. The best eyeliner for lash extensions will save your day a big time so definitely check out all the categories.

✨ Next Attraction: Top 11 Best Eyeshadow Palette for Soft Summer In 2023